Love Letters
- Description
- Reviews
- Citation
- Cataloging
- Transcript
Love Letters tells the remarkable story of esteemed professor and feminist scholar Catharine R. Stimpson and Australian musicologist Elizabeth (Liz) Wood. Now in their 80s, they recall a time when living openly and loving unapologetically was a radical act. For Catharine, this jeopardized her career and relationships with her family. The stakes were even higher for Liz as the mother of four children at a time when judges routinely denied custody to lesbians. Driven by their fierce desire to be together at all costs, Liz battled in Australian family court to be able to bring the children to New York and forge a life with Catharine. Liz’s lesbianism was used against her in court despite the children’s firm desire to remain with her. Ultimately, with Catharine’s unwavering support and that of feminist communities in Australia and New York, including luminaries such as Kate Millet, Adrienne Rich and Rita Mae Brown, Liz prevailed. Her victory established the precedent that lesbian mothers could not be considered unfit simply for who they love, and secured their life together as a family for the next five decades. Both women are motivated to tell their story now as younger generations wage their own battles against the patriarchy.
Cheryl Crooks | CASCADIA International Women's Film Festival
"Love Letters is a profound and heartfelt film beautifully unfolded by director Greta Schiller. The story of the two women who courageously challenged the child custody system at a time when it was radical for a lesbian couple to do so is touching, personal and genuinely moving. CASCADIA is excited and honored to give it the world premiere."
Citation
Main credits
Schiller, Greta (film director)
Schiller, Greta (film producer)
Other credits
Cinematography, Greta Schiller, Emmanuel Adu-Poku, Alex Meillier; editor, Alex Meillier.
Distributor subjects
Female Solidarity,Lesbian Motherhood,Families, Elderly,LoverKeywords
00:00:11.594 --> 00:00:16.308
(applause)
(indistinct chatter)
00:00:16.474 --> 00:00:19.227
(crowd cheering)
00:00:20.562 --> 00:00:24.107
♪ If they ask me I could write a book ♪
00:00:24.107 --> 00:00:27.319
♪ About the way you walk and whisper ♪
00:00:27.319 --> 00:00:29.362
♪ And look ♪
00:00:29.362 --> 00:00:31.781
♪ Then the world discovers ♪
00:00:32.657 --> 00:00:35.493
♪ How our book ends ♪
00:00:35.493 --> 00:00:40.165
♪ How to make a marriage begin ♪
00:00:40.165 --> 00:00:41.791
- [Off Camera] Oh, very sweet.
00:00:41.791 --> 00:00:44.461
(upbeat music)
00:00:45.503 --> 00:00:47.714
♪ If they ask me, ♪
00:00:47.714 --> 00:00:51.176
♪ I could write a book ♪
00:00:51.176 --> 00:00:56.181
♪ About the way you
walk, whisper and look. ♪
00:00:58.141 --> 00:01:03.146
♪ I could write a preface on how we met ♪
00:01:04.522 --> 00:01:06.608
- [Interviewer] Do you believe
in love at first sight?
00:01:06.608 --> 00:01:07.817
- Yes.
- Yes.
00:01:12.822 --> 00:01:15.909
- March 19th, 1977,
00:01:18.244 --> 00:01:21.706
I was living in an artist's
loft of the Bowery.
00:01:22.582 --> 00:01:25.710
It was a large loft, it had a skylight.
00:01:25.710 --> 00:01:27.587
It was very hot in the summer
00:01:27.587 --> 00:01:28.963
and very cold in the winter.
00:01:31.132 --> 00:01:33.301
I was editing Signs at that time
00:01:33.301 --> 00:01:36.137
and we really wanted to set
up international networks.
00:01:38.139 --> 00:01:40.892
And so if you walked in
00:01:40.892 --> 00:01:43.895
from any place in the world,
00:01:43.895 --> 00:01:47.816
Antarctica or the Arctic Circle,
00:01:47.816 --> 00:01:48.942
we wanted to see you.
00:01:48.942 --> 00:01:51.194
We wanted to find out what was going on.
00:01:51.986 --> 00:01:55.448
And Liz was in the United States,
00:01:55.448 --> 00:01:56.825
from Adelaide, Australia,
00:01:56.825 --> 00:01:58.993
on a Fulbright to study music.
00:01:59.953 --> 00:02:03.540
And I invited her to come for a drink.
00:02:03.957 --> 00:02:05.667
- [Interviewer] How did
you get to that loft?
00:02:05.667 --> 00:02:08.211
- You mean, you're giving
me a chance to edit that?
00:02:10.213 --> 00:02:14.634
I arrived in New York,
prepared to be dazzled,
00:02:14.634 --> 00:02:16.719
but utterly exhausted.
00:02:16.719 --> 00:02:18.263
And it's summer in Australia
00:02:18.263 --> 00:02:19.973
and it's winter in New York.
00:02:21.182 --> 00:02:24.102
So I arrived in Kennedy and it's snowing.
00:02:24.102 --> 00:02:26.187
And this is the first snow for me.
00:02:27.397 --> 00:02:28.648
I was enchanted.
00:02:30.275 --> 00:02:32.360
And I got a cabby.
00:02:32.360 --> 00:02:35.864
And as we drove past, I
remember Madison Avenue
00:02:35.864 --> 00:02:38.533
and all the canopies and
the uniform door men,
00:02:38.533 --> 00:02:41.828
and I thought, "This is Operetta!"
00:02:42.787 --> 00:02:46.624
I was a specialist in grand opera,
00:02:46.624 --> 00:02:51.546
so this was really
theatrical and stupendous.
00:02:51.546 --> 00:02:54.632
And I was invited to stay, initially,
00:02:54.632 --> 00:02:56.885
with the professor who'd invited me.
00:02:56.885 --> 00:03:01.639
Arriving at his huge apartment
overlooking Central Park,
00:03:01.639 --> 00:03:05.393
I thought it was the most
gorgeous place in the world.
00:03:05.393 --> 00:03:08.229
And there was an Australian guy there.
00:03:08.229 --> 00:03:10.773
He said, oh, just drop your bag.
00:03:10.773 --> 00:03:13.067
We hopped on the subway,
00:03:13.067 --> 00:03:15.945
we get off in Times Square, 1977.
00:03:17.322 --> 00:03:21.701
Filthy peep shows everywhere, flashers,
00:03:23.036 --> 00:03:26.498
but I said to myself, this
is where I've gotta be.
00:03:28.833 --> 00:03:30.793
So there I was in New York
00:03:30.793 --> 00:03:32.921
and I'd been in the city, I think,
00:03:32.921 --> 00:03:35.048
for a month or five weeks.
00:03:35.048 --> 00:03:39.344
So I'd been in many strange
lofts and tiny apartments.
00:03:40.303 --> 00:03:43.640
So I remember walking up
the stairs in my Frye boots,
00:03:43.640 --> 00:03:45.433
which I thought were the ants pants,
00:03:46.601 --> 00:03:48.144
and British bobby's cape,
00:03:48.144 --> 00:03:50.021
which I'd bought at Army and Navy,
00:03:51.272 --> 00:03:52.857
and meeting Catharine.
00:03:54.776 --> 00:03:57.403
And the drink extended to dinner.
00:03:57.403 --> 00:04:00.114
- We had marinated steak and asparagus.
00:04:00.114 --> 00:04:02.033
Then I said, well, if
you're going to be here,
00:04:02.033 --> 00:04:04.452
you're gonna have to watch
"The Mary Tyler Moore Show,"
00:04:04.452 --> 00:04:06.704
because it's an American moment.
00:04:06.704 --> 00:04:10.375
An American icon is having her last show.
00:04:12.293 --> 00:04:13.920
- I don't have a job as of Monday.
00:04:13.920 --> 00:04:15.296
- Oh, we know.
00:04:15.296 --> 00:04:16.714
Lou told us when he called.
00:04:16.714 --> 00:04:19.259
Yeah, it's obviously a case
of sexual discrimination.
00:04:19.259 --> 00:04:20.593
- Oh, no, no. Phil.
00:04:20.593 --> 00:04:22.262
They fired the guys too.
00:04:22.262 --> 00:04:23.763
- Oh, Mary, you little goose!
00:04:25.056 --> 00:04:27.183
It was just to cover their tracks.
00:04:27.183 --> 00:04:29.894
- [Kate] So we watched the
"Mary Tyler Moore Show,"
00:04:29.894 --> 00:04:33.940
and then we just talked
and talked and talked.
00:04:33.940 --> 00:04:37.360
- And then just as I thought
she was really interested
00:04:37.360 --> 00:04:40.238
in the research and I was
doing my dissertation,
00:04:41.864 --> 00:04:43.700
she asked about my children,
00:04:43.700 --> 00:04:45.577
'cause I said I had four children.
00:04:45.577 --> 00:04:48.788
And I had no idea that she was
00:04:48.788 --> 00:04:50.790
the second of six children.
00:04:50.790 --> 00:04:53.084
- Seven.
- Seven children, sorry.
00:04:53.084 --> 00:04:55.962
So she came from this huge family.
00:04:55.962 --> 00:04:58.965
To her, four children was kind of a blink.
00:04:59.924 --> 00:05:03.636
I remember saying to you,
can I tell this story?
00:05:03.636 --> 00:05:05.555
Yes, I must tell this story.
00:05:05.555 --> 00:05:07.724
I remember in the course of
the evening saying to her,
00:05:07.724 --> 00:05:09.225
listen, leaning forward and saying,
00:05:09.225 --> 00:05:11.769
Catharine, don't get the wrong idea.
00:05:12.729 --> 00:05:15.523
I have four children, but I'm also a dyke.
00:05:15.523 --> 00:05:18.401
And she literally flinched.
00:05:18.401 --> 00:05:21.487
She went into a kind of paraxism.
00:05:21.487 --> 00:05:25.992
Because no one was, in polite
circles, was using that term.
00:05:25.992 --> 00:05:28.911
Only raunchy Australians
would say things like that.
00:05:29.829 --> 00:05:32.415
So we then had to move
on from that moment.
00:05:34.751 --> 00:05:38.087
And eventually she sort of said, stay.
00:05:40.798 --> 00:05:42.592
And in the middle of the night,
00:05:43.509 --> 00:05:46.929
she got up on one elbow and she said,
00:05:46.929 --> 00:05:48.765
I think I'm falling in love with you.
00:05:49.641 --> 00:05:52.393
I remember telling myself to keep my head.
00:05:54.103 --> 00:05:55.104
♪ I don't know what it is ♪
00:05:55.104 --> 00:05:57.440
♪ That makes me love you so. ♪
00:05:57.440 --> 00:06:01.069
♪ I only know I never wanna let you go ♪
00:06:01.069 --> 00:06:02.737
♪ 'Cause you started something ♪
00:06:02.737 --> 00:06:04.614
♪ Oh can't you see ♪
00:06:04.614 --> 00:06:08.159
♪ But ever since we met
you had a hold on me, ♪
00:06:08.159 --> 00:06:11.788
♪ It happens to be true ♪
00:06:11.788 --> 00:06:16.793
♪ I only wanna be with you. ♪
00:06:18.002 --> 00:06:19.420
I remember thinking,
00:06:19.420 --> 00:06:21.714
here, I can be who I want to be.
00:06:21.714 --> 00:06:23.883
Here, I can be myself.
00:06:23.883 --> 00:06:27.095
But for a long time I was very confused.
00:06:28.054 --> 00:06:31.808
At school, as a little girl,
00:06:32.642 --> 00:06:35.353
I had what you would call
a crush on our teacher.
00:06:37.355 --> 00:06:40.441
I'd been a tomboy, climbing trees,
00:06:40.441 --> 00:06:42.276
I had clubs of fellow girls
00:06:42.276 --> 00:06:45.029
who were dragooned into my clubs.
00:06:46.906 --> 00:06:48.574
My mother, my father,
00:06:48.574 --> 00:06:52.161
they were very fearful
that I was different;
00:06:52.161 --> 00:06:53.287
not in the norm.
00:06:54.914 --> 00:06:57.041
But I knew there was
something really wrong
00:06:57.041 --> 00:06:59.419
the year after I left school,
00:06:59.419 --> 00:07:02.797
when I was doing psychology
one at Adelaide University,
00:07:02.797 --> 00:07:07.009
and I asked a girl if I could
do a study of her desires.
00:07:07.009 --> 00:07:10.847
It was one of our
required research topics.
00:07:11.889 --> 00:07:15.059
And her father, after he had
00:07:15.059 --> 00:07:17.937
probably listened to my questions,
00:07:17.937 --> 00:07:20.106
actually rushed me out of the house
00:07:20.106 --> 00:07:21.691
and told me never to come back.
00:07:22.608 --> 00:07:24.444
And I began to realize that
00:07:24.444 --> 00:07:26.112
the sort of things that I was interested
00:07:26.112 --> 00:07:28.781
in asking other girls, were taboo.
00:07:30.116 --> 00:07:32.034
As a woman going to university,
00:07:32.034 --> 00:07:34.579
the Adelaide Advertiser
took pictures of me,
00:07:34.579 --> 00:07:37.081
because no one left home.
00:07:37.081 --> 00:07:38.124
I had a flat!
00:07:40.293 --> 00:07:42.837
I mean, I was marked for sin.
00:07:44.756 --> 00:07:47.508
And then as university students,
00:07:47.508 --> 00:07:50.928
Sue Bettison and I were lovers.
00:07:50.928 --> 00:07:53.765
And of course we'd gone out with boys,
00:07:53.765 --> 00:07:55.391
but we were lovers.
00:07:55.391 --> 00:07:58.895
And that, to us, didn't
seem at all deviant.
00:08:00.188 --> 00:08:01.898
But I always assumed
00:08:01.898 --> 00:08:03.733
that I would have children at some point.
00:08:03.733 --> 00:08:05.526
I remember fiercely wanting children,
00:08:05.526 --> 00:08:08.362
because I wanted the family I didn't have;
00:08:08.362 --> 00:08:10.323
a close and loving family.
00:08:10.323 --> 00:08:11.741
And Sue did too.
00:08:11.741 --> 00:08:15.453
So we married business partners,
00:08:15.453 --> 00:08:19.624
Alistair Wood, engineer, Jim Bettison,
00:08:21.584 --> 00:08:23.169
- Administrator.
- Administrator,
00:08:23.169 --> 00:08:25.004
financial officer.
00:08:25.004 --> 00:08:27.298
They would come around to our flat
00:08:27.298 --> 00:08:29.091
in their little sports cars,
00:08:29.091 --> 00:08:31.469
and have coffee or bring us liqueur,
00:08:31.469 --> 00:08:33.054
and then they'd go back to work.
00:08:34.055 --> 00:08:35.389
They knew we were lesbians.
00:08:35.389 --> 00:08:37.934
We said we were lesbians.
00:08:37.934 --> 00:08:41.145
I remember Alistair saying
to me, that's all right.
00:08:41.145 --> 00:08:41.979
That's okay.
00:08:43.523 --> 00:08:46.442
- [Priest] Who giveth this
woman to be married to this man?
00:08:47.527 --> 00:08:49.320
- [Liz] So what would be more logical
00:08:49.320 --> 00:08:50.404
than marrying Alistair,
00:08:50.404 --> 00:08:53.407
who I had always found a romantic figure,
00:08:53.407 --> 00:08:56.577
dark, bearded, mysterious.
00:09:00.122 --> 00:09:02.625
But he was a brilliant mathematician
00:09:02.625 --> 00:09:04.627
and he was a workaholic.
00:09:05.628 --> 00:09:08.172
So Sue and I married business partners
00:09:08.172 --> 00:09:11.676
and Sue and I continued to
create a family together.
00:09:11.676 --> 00:09:13.886
This sounds utterly insane,
00:09:13.886 --> 00:09:16.681
but for two lesbians,
it was quite supportive.
00:09:16.681 --> 00:09:18.391
(child singing indistinctly)
00:09:18.391 --> 00:09:20.226
- [Off Camera] Bloody hell!
00:09:21.227 --> 00:09:22.895
- [Liz] We were a family.
00:09:22.895 --> 00:09:24.939
We lived across the
Parklands from each other.
00:09:24.939 --> 00:09:26.274
We raised these babies.
00:09:27.316 --> 00:09:28.985
- [Children] ♪ They say I killed a man ♪
00:09:28.985 --> 00:09:30.111
♪ Killed a man ♪
00:09:30.111 --> 00:09:31.863
♪ Killed a man. ♪
00:09:31.863 --> 00:09:34.949
♪ They say I killed a man, ♪
00:09:34.949 --> 00:09:36.576
♪ I hit him on the head ♪
00:09:36.576 --> 00:09:38.828
♪ With some bloody leg ♪
00:09:38.828 --> 00:09:41.330
- [Liz] But what really
then kiboshed all of this
00:09:41.330 --> 00:09:43.708
was that once I started seriously
00:09:43.708 --> 00:09:45.877
to examine my feminist beliefs
00:09:45.877 --> 00:09:48.546
and going to consciousness raising groups
00:09:48.546 --> 00:09:50.131
and meeting other women,
00:09:50.131 --> 00:09:53.426
I realized the illogicality
of how I was living;
00:09:53.426 --> 00:09:56.262
that I had two lives.
00:09:56.262 --> 00:09:58.055
I think I was going a little crazy.
00:09:59.015 --> 00:10:00.558
- And I think it all starts, really,
00:10:00.558 --> 00:10:03.102
with an individual sort of awakening.
00:10:03.102 --> 00:10:04.478
- Yeah, why should it be prescribed
00:10:04.478 --> 00:10:05.688
for women to be feminine,
00:10:05.688 --> 00:10:06.522
for men being masculine?
- [Participant] I think we
00:10:06.522 --> 00:10:08.232
we should define what is feminine
00:10:08.232 --> 00:10:10.151
before we even start discussing it.
00:10:10.151 --> 00:10:11.944
- Because when you look at it,
00:10:11.944 --> 00:10:14.822
I think it's a whole way of
relating to other people,
00:10:14.822 --> 00:10:15.907
specifically men,
00:10:15.907 --> 00:10:18.576
not fighting for what you want.
00:10:18.576 --> 00:10:22.246
Femininity is, I guess, a
great pointless martyrdom.
00:10:23.623 --> 00:10:27.043
- [Liz] I was having
the odd fling with women
00:10:27.043 --> 00:10:30.338
and behaving badly, I
would say, on the whole.
00:10:30.338 --> 00:10:33.883
And I think I needed to be
reigned in at that point,
00:10:33.883 --> 00:10:38.137
but I was busting out of the confines
00:10:38.137 --> 00:10:42.516
of this conservative
family that I married into
00:10:42.516 --> 00:10:44.268
and the anxious,
00:10:46.145 --> 00:10:48.731
tense family I had come from,
00:10:48.731 --> 00:10:50.983
and trying to understand
what the heck was going on,
00:10:50.983 --> 00:10:55.029
because feminism was new there too.
00:10:55.029 --> 00:10:58.157
And so this was a ferment of ideas.
00:10:58.157 --> 00:10:59.408
You know, the sorts of things
00:10:59.408 --> 00:11:01.369
that Adelaide feminists were doing,
00:11:01.369 --> 00:11:03.454
was that we were liberating bars,
00:11:03.454 --> 00:11:07.124
Australian bars, pubs, were men only.
00:11:07.124 --> 00:11:10.878
(indistinct chatter)
00:11:10.878 --> 00:11:12.713
- [Patron] Hand away for me, sir.
00:11:12.713 --> 00:11:14.256
- It's not me hand, it's only me finger.
00:11:14.256 --> 00:11:15.841
- Well just remove your finger, will you?
00:11:15.841 --> 00:11:16.926
And I can go and,
00:11:16.926 --> 00:11:18.177
- Well what you asked is,
00:11:18.177 --> 00:11:21.013
what happens when a woman comes in.
00:11:21.013 --> 00:11:22.223
- And we'd march down the streets
00:11:22.223 --> 00:11:23.849
of little old Adelaide.
00:11:25.768 --> 00:11:27.645
I have to say, it was liberating,
00:11:27.645 --> 00:11:31.315
but I'd then go home to the four children
00:11:31.315 --> 00:11:33.067
who were being babysat by my students,
00:11:33.067 --> 00:11:34.443
because I was also teaching
00:11:34.443 --> 00:11:35.903
at Adelaide University at this time
00:11:35.903 --> 00:11:37.780
and doing many other things.
00:11:37.780 --> 00:11:40.282
It was all exciting, but chaotic,
00:11:40.282 --> 00:11:43.869
and there was absolutely no clear path.
00:11:43.869 --> 00:11:46.831
I didn't have the vision
of where I was going,
00:11:46.831 --> 00:11:48.499
until I met Catharine.
00:11:49.583 --> 00:11:50.584
She knew.
00:11:50.584 --> 00:11:52.545
She knew that first night
00:11:52.545 --> 00:11:54.588
what the likely future was.
00:11:58.300 --> 00:12:00.052
- In my time,
00:12:00.052 --> 00:12:03.681
your coming out was scary.
00:12:03.681 --> 00:12:08.519
Right, 3-7-17-26-39-41.
00:12:09.729 --> 00:12:12.398
And part of this, is you
had to come out to yourself.
00:12:14.358 --> 00:12:17.737
And that meant dealing with
internalized homophobia.
00:12:18.696 --> 00:12:21.157
And that took me a very long time.
00:12:22.408 --> 00:12:24.660
Wednesday, June 8th, 77,
00:12:26.662 --> 00:12:28.706
"Well my darling, your letter arrived."
00:12:28.706 --> 00:12:29.540
This is it.
00:12:31.959 --> 00:12:35.212
Coming out to family, very hard.
00:12:37.298 --> 00:12:39.759
- [Interviewer] You got it?
- This is it.
00:12:39.759 --> 00:12:40.593
Work?
00:12:41.802 --> 00:12:43.095
No, no way.
00:12:45.014 --> 00:12:47.808
Between you and my archives,
00:12:47.808 --> 00:12:50.770
everything is now permanently unlocked.
00:12:50.770 --> 00:12:52.605
I've lived with so many secrets,
00:12:53.564 --> 00:12:57.193
and now deliberately, willfully,
00:12:58.152 --> 00:13:00.905
I have said, let all the secrets spill out
00:13:00.905 --> 00:13:04.241
and preserve all this fragile paper
00:13:04.241 --> 00:13:05.701
so the secrets can be read.
00:13:06.702 --> 00:13:08.704
- [Interviewer] Why do
you wanna do it now?
00:13:08.704 --> 00:13:09.997
- Because I'm going to die
00:13:10.873 --> 00:13:14.627
and I don't wanna die with
all this going up in flames.
00:13:18.380 --> 00:13:22.218
Liz and I lived a kind of deep life,
00:13:25.471 --> 00:13:26.305
and
00:13:27.890 --> 00:13:29.141
I want that known.
00:13:32.561 --> 00:13:35.648
(gentle piano music)
00:13:39.068 --> 00:13:40.986
I met Liz when I was 40
00:13:42.154 --> 00:13:44.990
and I had lived a lesbian life
00:13:44.990 --> 00:13:46.450
for several years, by then.
00:13:47.493 --> 00:13:49.203
I'd had relationships.
00:13:49.203 --> 00:13:51.580
I'd had a very long-term relationship.
00:13:51.580 --> 00:13:54.250
I had been through a terrible tenure case
00:13:54.250 --> 00:13:57.044
where my lesbianism had
been used against me.
00:13:57.044 --> 00:14:00.965
So I was no longer this
psychological child,
00:14:00.965 --> 00:14:02.591
saying, what are these feelings?
00:14:03.717 --> 00:14:08.639
I mean, I had, after I came
out, rather a rich life.
00:14:08.639 --> 00:14:10.516
But it took me a long time.
00:14:10.516 --> 00:14:12.518
It took me several years
00:14:12.518 --> 00:14:15.312
before I could come to terms.
00:14:15.312 --> 00:14:19.066
And when I realized I was
a deviant dyke lesbian,
00:14:19.066 --> 00:14:23.320
my fear of being all those bad words
00:14:23.320 --> 00:14:26.866
was the sense of social
ostracism that would come.
00:14:28.701 --> 00:14:30.161
And I went through a passage
00:14:30.161 --> 00:14:32.913
that I think many women of
my generation went through.
00:14:33.747 --> 00:14:35.708
First we were heterosexual,
00:14:35.708 --> 00:14:38.169
then we were bisexual,
00:14:38.169 --> 00:14:40.921
and then finally, we were homosexual.
00:14:42.548 --> 00:14:46.886
There was a passage with stops and starts.
00:14:47.845 --> 00:14:50.347
But I was surrounded by
a feminist community,
00:14:53.309 --> 00:14:55.603
surrounded by people who were coming out.
00:14:58.772 --> 00:15:00.524
I think it also, Greta, has something to do
00:15:00.524 --> 00:15:01.984
with the strength of desire.
00:15:03.152 --> 00:15:05.029
At some point,
00:15:05.029 --> 00:15:09.325
desire to be in the world
where you wish to be,
00:15:11.076 --> 00:15:15.789
has its own drumbeat, its own flags,
00:15:15.789 --> 00:15:17.917
its own imperatives,
00:15:17.917 --> 00:15:21.045
its own risks and its own rewards.
00:15:23.172 --> 00:15:25.299
And so by the time I met Liz,
00:15:26.300 --> 00:15:27.593
I was a lesbian
00:15:29.178 --> 00:15:30.971
who was aware of desire.
00:15:32.139 --> 00:15:34.183
And I also had, at this point,
00:15:34.183 --> 00:15:35.768
had the nerve to act on it.
00:15:37.603 --> 00:15:40.773
A lot of people came through that loft.
00:15:41.857 --> 00:15:43.525
She was the one
00:15:43.525 --> 00:15:46.362
that I didn't want to
have leave that loft.
00:15:47.404 --> 00:15:50.407
- I was visiting New York for three months
00:15:50.407 --> 00:15:52.409
and I was meeting the most exciting person
00:15:52.409 --> 00:15:54.036
I'd ever met.
00:15:54.036 --> 00:15:56.080
A brilliant, brilliant woman.
00:15:57.164 --> 00:15:59.833
An intellectual leader
of the women's movement.
00:16:01.001 --> 00:16:03.796
And through her, meeting a whole ton
00:16:03.796 --> 00:16:07.675
of the most fascinating women
who were remaking the world.
00:16:07.675 --> 00:16:11.553
I remember, I had read Kate
Millett's book, "Flying,"
00:16:12.846 --> 00:16:15.516
not knowing that she's a character in it.
00:16:15.516 --> 00:16:17.393
I met Millett soon after.
00:16:17.393 --> 00:16:18.227
- [David Frost] Do you not believe
00:16:18.227 --> 00:16:19.478
a woman's place is in the home, right?
00:16:19.478 --> 00:16:21.814
- As feminists, what we
believe in is very simple.
00:16:21.814 --> 00:16:23.857
And that is the social, economic
00:16:23.857 --> 00:16:26.527
and political equality of the sexes.
00:16:26.527 --> 00:16:28.612
Because the relationship
between the sexes is,
00:16:28.612 --> 00:16:30.864
in fact, a political relationship.
00:16:30.864 --> 00:16:32.283
We're an oppressed group
00:16:32.283 --> 00:16:33.909
and we have been through history.
00:16:33.909 --> 00:16:35.369
- I mean, I walked straight into
00:16:35.369 --> 00:16:39.039
the powerhouse of the women's
movement in New York City.
00:16:39.915 --> 00:16:41.500
♪ Here she comes, ♪
00:16:41.500 --> 00:16:43.085
♪ Walking down the street ♪
00:16:43.085 --> 00:16:44.795
♪ Here she comes, ♪
00:16:44.795 --> 00:16:46.505
♪ Coming through my door ♪
00:16:46.505 --> 00:16:48.215
♪ Here she comes, ♪
00:16:48.215 --> 00:16:50.009
♪ Crawling up my stair ♪
00:16:50.009 --> 00:16:51.677
♪ Here she comes, ♪
00:16:51.677 --> 00:16:53.595
♪ Waltzing through the hall ♪
00:16:53.595 --> 00:16:55.431
♪ In a pretty red dress ♪
00:16:55.431 --> 00:16:58.809
♪ And oh, she looks so good ♪
00:16:58.809 --> 00:17:02.229
♪ Oh, she looks so fine ♪
00:17:02.229 --> 00:17:04.773
♪ And I got this crazy feeling ♪
00:17:04.773 --> 00:17:07.568
♪ I'm gonna uh-uh make her mine ♪
00:17:07.568 --> 00:17:10.654
- It was a psychological
ferment, a social ferment,
00:17:10.654 --> 00:17:13.782
an intellectual ferment,
an artistic ferment,
00:17:13.782 --> 00:17:16.160
where all sorts of
conversations were going on.
00:17:17.036 --> 00:17:21.373
In New York, there was place
after place after place,
00:17:21.373 --> 00:17:25.377
where you could go and say
what you were trying to do
00:17:25.377 --> 00:17:28.047
and people would say,
that's beautiful. Do it.
00:17:29.006 --> 00:17:31.842
Wherever you might go,
you would find energy
00:17:31.842 --> 00:17:34.595
and creativity and rebellion.
00:17:34.595 --> 00:17:36.055
And it was there.
00:17:36.055 --> 00:17:40.059
It was a context in which you could take
00:17:40.059 --> 00:17:42.186
what was once thought to be deviance,
00:17:43.103 --> 00:17:47.858
and have it become a way
of living creatively.
00:17:47.858 --> 00:17:50.361
- It was a feminist revolution.
00:17:50.361 --> 00:17:52.988
It was so exciting, intellectually,
00:17:52.988 --> 00:17:57.159
emotionally, politically, sexually,
00:17:57.159 --> 00:18:00.579
that I had to get a grip and say,
00:18:00.579 --> 00:18:02.081
I've gotta go home.
00:18:02.081 --> 00:18:06.210
♪ I'm leaving on a jet plane ♪
00:18:06.210 --> 00:18:10.672
♪ I don't know when I'll be back again ♪
00:18:10.672 --> 00:18:15.677
♪ Oh babe, I hate to go. ♪
00:18:16.929 --> 00:18:20.891
- [Liz] And it was absolutely
glorious to be with the kids.
00:18:20.891 --> 00:18:23.143
All of them were in very good shape.
00:18:23.143 --> 00:18:26.146
I hadn't been gone long
enough for problems to arise.
00:18:27.481 --> 00:18:29.650
And I was trying to work out
00:18:29.650 --> 00:18:31.568
ending the marriage with Alistair,
00:18:31.568 --> 00:18:34.530
but coming to an agreed upon negotiation
00:18:34.530 --> 00:18:36.448
to the future of the kids.
00:18:36.448 --> 00:18:39.868
And I remember, the first
negotiation was very painful.
00:18:39.868 --> 00:18:42.246
I'd been there for about two or three days
00:18:42.246 --> 00:18:44.832
and I raised this several times with him.
00:18:44.832 --> 00:18:46.625
He didn't want to talk about it.
00:18:46.625 --> 00:18:49.586
He was angry, we were sort of fighting.
00:18:49.586 --> 00:18:50.629
I had to get out.
00:18:52.506 --> 00:18:55.634
Long distance phone calls cost a fortune.
00:18:55.634 --> 00:18:56.885
I remember thinking,
00:18:56.885 --> 00:18:58.804
we've had so many phone calls
00:18:58.804 --> 00:19:00.222
I could have flown back to New York
00:19:00.222 --> 00:19:02.808
and back to Adelaide at the same cost.
00:19:05.769 --> 00:19:07.563
Catharine and I wrote air letters,
00:19:07.563 --> 00:19:11.442
which took two weeks to arrive,
00:19:11.442 --> 00:19:13.277
and tapes we would make.
00:19:16.113 --> 00:19:18.574
- [Liz On Tape] Well
darling, isn't it wonderful?
00:19:20.159 --> 00:19:23.328
Our letters and our tapes have met.
00:19:25.080 --> 00:19:29.585
Our great network,
reaching across the ocean.
00:19:29.585 --> 00:19:30.544
Aren't we clever?
00:19:31.795 --> 00:19:33.088
I think we're brilliant.
00:19:34.882 --> 00:19:35.799
Oh darling,
00:19:38.093 --> 00:19:43.098
I have a great, sure, serene sense
00:19:44.975 --> 00:19:46.810
of us lasting together
00:19:48.770 --> 00:19:50.522
for simply ages.
00:19:52.858 --> 00:19:57.196
My octogenarian lover.
00:19:59.948 --> 00:20:01.450
- I was over there and it was agony.
00:20:01.450 --> 00:20:03.118
I mean, we were desperate,
00:20:03.118 --> 00:20:03.952
Catharine and me.
00:20:03.952 --> 00:20:07.247
We were parted. It was unbearable.
00:20:08.207 --> 00:20:09.500
- Do you reckon if I go over there
00:20:09.500 --> 00:20:10.501
for another couple of months,
00:20:10.501 --> 00:20:12.252
you could manage again, couldn't you?
00:20:12.252 --> 00:20:13.378
- Yeah.
- No.
00:20:13.378 --> 00:20:15.714
- No!
- Don't you think it could?
00:20:15.714 --> 00:20:17.591
It went pretty quickly.
00:20:17.591 --> 00:20:18.425
And while you're at school,
00:20:18.425 --> 00:20:19.259
- For you, not for us.
00:20:19.259 --> 00:20:21.470
- No, but listen: while you're at school,
00:20:21.470 --> 00:20:22.513
- I do mind!
00:20:22.513 --> 00:20:25.349
- Knowing that we'd
always be together again.
00:20:25.349 --> 00:20:26.767
- Always. You're not
allowed to part from me.
00:20:26.767 --> 00:20:28.101
- You're right, it's my decision.
00:20:28.101 --> 00:20:29.853
But I have to always consider the fact
00:20:29.853 --> 00:20:31.271
that I love you all dearly
00:20:31.271 --> 00:20:33.524
and I'd prefer you to be with me.
00:20:33.524 --> 00:20:36.818
I had to ask for a credit card
00:20:36.818 --> 00:20:38.529
because in those days,
00:20:38.529 --> 00:20:42.074
married women could
not have a credit card.
00:20:42.074 --> 00:20:43.909
They had to be supplementary
to their husband's.
00:20:43.909 --> 00:20:46.537
That is hard to believe today.
00:20:46.537 --> 00:20:49.206
And I had to get Sue's
husband to organize it.
00:20:49.206 --> 00:20:50.832
'Cause Alastair refused to do it.
00:20:52.626 --> 00:20:54.169
- [Kate On Tape] Tomorrow
it'll be almost four weeks
00:20:54.169 --> 00:20:55.671
since I put you on that plane.
00:20:56.880 --> 00:20:59.591
I'm still stunned that you're coming back.
00:21:01.051 --> 00:21:03.095
It's like a tremendous gift.
00:21:03.095 --> 00:21:04.972
- So I said I was going back,
00:21:04.972 --> 00:21:07.266
and it would be for about four months.
00:21:09.393 --> 00:21:13.522
♪ 'Cause we're women-loving-women ♪
00:21:13.522 --> 00:21:16.316
♪ We’ll sing it loud and long. ♪
00:21:16.316 --> 00:21:19.987
♪ Yeah, we're sisters united ♪
00:21:19.987 --> 00:21:24.992
♪ And the love is oh-so strong ♪
00:21:25.075 --> 00:21:26.910
♪ Some say our craze is ♪
00:21:26.910 --> 00:21:29.830
♪ an Amazon phase ♪
00:21:29.830 --> 00:21:33.709
♪ But soon they'll see ♪
00:21:33.709 --> 00:21:36.253
♪ That we're women-loving-women ♪
00:21:36.253 --> 00:21:39.423
♪ And that's all we'll be ♪
00:21:39.423 --> 00:21:40.465
- And when I came back,
00:21:40.465 --> 00:21:43.969
I had an apartment in Charles Street
00:21:45.095 --> 00:21:48.098
and the apartment I was in was
Rita Mae Brown's apartment,
00:21:48.098 --> 00:21:51.101
Rita Ma Brown, famous
for "Rubyfruit Jungle"
00:21:51.101 --> 00:21:54.187
and other salaciously
gorgeous lesbian novels
00:21:54.187 --> 00:21:55.939
of the early seventies.
00:21:55.939 --> 00:21:57.065
And she would come in
00:21:57.065 --> 00:21:59.109
only for one weekend out of four,
00:21:59.109 --> 00:22:02.154
so I was able to settle in her
apartment in Charles Street
00:22:02.154 --> 00:22:05.657
and get the bulk of volume
two of the dissertation done.
00:22:05.657 --> 00:22:09.911
And it would be those weekly
letters to the children.
00:22:09.911 --> 00:22:12.205
They would make tapes and send them back.
00:22:12.205 --> 00:22:14.499
- [Child 1] Testing,
testing, one, two, three.
00:22:16.627 --> 00:22:17.836
- [Child 2] Mountain Dew.
00:22:19.296 --> 00:22:20.464
Rome, Paris
00:22:20.464 --> 00:22:23.216
- Man with the microphone.
00:22:26.178 --> 00:22:27.554
Join in if you like, mum.
00:22:27.554 --> 00:22:30.140
- And I would try and devise letters
00:22:30.140 --> 00:22:32.476
that would engage them.
00:22:32.476 --> 00:22:35.646
I would write with stuck in pictures
00:22:35.646 --> 00:22:38.565
from magazines or the
newspaper to tell a narrative.
00:22:42.694 --> 00:22:44.946
So at about this time,
00:22:44.946 --> 00:22:46.323
I was beginning to get news
00:22:46.323 --> 00:22:49.534
from my mother and from a neighbor,
00:22:49.534 --> 00:22:53.288
that the family was fraying.
00:22:53.288 --> 00:22:56.917
There were problems and
that I needed to come home.
00:22:58.168 --> 00:23:01.630
- I knew I had to go to
Australia to meet the children,
00:23:01.630 --> 00:23:05.759
because despite the
passion, despite the love,
00:23:05.759 --> 00:23:10.764
if we couldn't be together with
the children supporting it,
00:23:12.307 --> 00:23:13.517
it just couldn't happen.
00:23:14.976 --> 00:23:15.811
- [Child 1] Are we on tape?
00:23:15.811 --> 00:23:17.437
- [Liz On Tape] Yes, I'm making
a tape for Kate Stimpson.
00:23:17.437 --> 00:23:19.398
This is my friend in New
York who's very special,
00:23:19.398 --> 00:23:23.944
who's coming, so you'll have
this real, live American.
00:23:23.944 --> 00:23:25.404
- [Child] Does she talk American?
00:23:25.404 --> 00:23:27.781
- [Liz On Tape] Oh yes, of
course she talks American.
00:23:27.781 --> 00:23:28.824
- [Child] Oh, goodie!
00:23:28.824 --> 00:23:30.575
- [Liz On Tape] Do you know
what they call "herbs?"
00:23:30.575 --> 00:23:31.952
- [Child 3] No?
- [Liz On Tape] Herbs.
00:23:31.952 --> 00:23:34.788
(children laughing)
00:23:34.788 --> 00:23:36.164
- At one point I went to Alistair
00:23:36.164 --> 00:23:37.833
and he was in the study.
00:23:37.833 --> 00:23:41.837
and I said, Alistair, I'm
very happy to go to a hotel
00:23:41.837 --> 00:23:43.296
and not be here.
00:23:43.296 --> 00:23:44.464
And he said, no, no, it's okay.
00:23:44.464 --> 00:23:46.383
It's all right. It's all right.
00:23:46.383 --> 00:23:49.052
- For Alistair, I actually
feel very sorry for him
00:23:49.052 --> 00:23:52.055
because he didn't know
what the heck was going on.
00:23:52.055 --> 00:23:53.390
Or he knew and didn't want to know.
00:23:53.390 --> 00:23:55.267
- But I remember thinking,
00:23:57.853 --> 00:23:59.479
you will get through this.
00:24:01.273 --> 00:24:03.400
You love her very much.
00:24:04.568 --> 00:24:06.194
You want to get to know the kids
00:24:06.194 --> 00:24:08.196
and the kids to know you,
00:24:08.196 --> 00:24:10.615
grit your teeth and get through it.
00:24:10.615 --> 00:24:13.577
- Yeah, but when she came
to Australia that Christmas,
00:24:14.411 --> 00:24:16.455
- The children, of course,
fell in love with her.
00:24:16.455 --> 00:24:18.206
How could they not?
00:24:18.206 --> 00:24:19.750
The big yank.
00:24:19.750 --> 00:24:21.543
- [Kate] I still remember
the presents I took.
00:24:21.543 --> 00:24:23.378
- [Liz] Oh, you were
charming and wonderful
00:24:23.378 --> 00:24:24.755
and they were very excited.
00:24:25.422 --> 00:24:27.758
There were parties of Adelaide feminists
00:24:27.758 --> 00:24:30.802
longing to meet the great attraction.
00:24:30.802 --> 00:24:33.472
♪ I think I'd like to get to know you ♪
00:24:33.472 --> 00:24:37.684
♪ In a special kind of womanly way ♪
00:24:37.684 --> 00:24:40.854
♪ Yeah yeah ♪
00:24:40.854 --> 00:24:41.980
- I went to Australia
00:24:41.980 --> 00:24:45.025
for the purpose of meeting the children.
00:24:45.025 --> 00:24:47.319
If the children had said no,
00:24:48.320 --> 00:24:50.280
then I would've gone back
00:24:51.156 --> 00:24:52.657
and that would've been it.
00:24:54.451 --> 00:24:56.620
- [Liz] In that period, I began to realize
00:24:56.620 --> 00:24:58.246
that the children really needed
00:24:58.246 --> 00:25:01.541
my day-to-day motherhood still.
00:25:02.793 --> 00:25:05.921
And I realized that we
had to fight for them.
00:25:05.921 --> 00:25:07.589
I saw a lawyer.
00:25:07.589 --> 00:25:08.924
I was working things out with you,
00:25:08.924 --> 00:25:11.176
in constant communications.
00:25:11.176 --> 00:25:12.886
I think there were a lot of letters then.
00:25:12.886 --> 00:25:15.806
I had to have a strategy, a plan.
00:25:15.806 --> 00:25:17.432
You can't just ask to have the children
00:25:17.432 --> 00:25:18.809
and take 'em to America.
00:25:18.809 --> 00:25:21.478
And he said, you are going
to need to find a school,
00:25:21.478 --> 00:25:24.815
an apartment which would
be safe and big enough,
00:25:24.815 --> 00:25:26.733
and I needed to find a job.
00:25:28.151 --> 00:25:33.156
- Remember, no lesbian
had ever won custody
00:25:33.281 --> 00:25:35.951
or joint custody of her kids.
00:25:37.536 --> 00:25:40.247
- [Film] Los Angeles, 1974,
00:25:40.247 --> 00:25:43.542
in a child custody case
involving a lesbian mother,
00:25:43.542 --> 00:25:46.086
the judge granted custody
of the women's two children
00:25:46.086 --> 00:25:48.338
to their grandparents in another state,
00:25:48.338 --> 00:25:49.714
despite the children's wishes
00:25:49.714 --> 00:25:51.716
to remain with their mother.
00:25:51.716 --> 00:25:53.510
- Motherhood was rooted, still,
00:25:53.510 --> 00:25:56.263
in the heterosexual family.
00:25:56.263 --> 00:25:59.766
And it took a long time
for that to be shaken.
00:25:59.766 --> 00:26:02.352
And on the whole, women
abandoned their children
00:26:02.352 --> 00:26:04.145
or had them taken away.
00:26:05.355 --> 00:26:07.315
- [Film] New York, 1976,
00:26:08.525 --> 00:26:11.403
a judge transferred custody
of a four-year-old girl
00:26:11.403 --> 00:26:13.655
from her mother to her father,
00:26:13.655 --> 00:26:16.825
saying that a woman has
the right to be a lesbian,
00:26:16.825 --> 00:26:19.911
but that lesbians don't have
the right to raise children.
00:26:21.496 --> 00:26:22.789
- I think part of the reason
00:26:22.789 --> 00:26:26.084
why people in Adelaide,
in the circles were,
00:26:26.084 --> 00:26:28.128
the school parents for example,
00:26:28.128 --> 00:26:30.380
were so appalled by what I was doing,
00:26:30.380 --> 00:26:32.257
was that it shook, in many ways,
00:26:32.257 --> 00:26:35.218
the foundation of their
beliefs in marriage.
00:26:35.218 --> 00:26:37.679
Very few of them were able
to discuss that with me.
00:26:37.679 --> 00:26:40.265
On the whole, I was shunned
00:26:40.265 --> 00:26:43.351
and I was told to my face, often,
00:26:43.351 --> 00:26:44.644
that I was doing the wrong thing,
00:26:44.644 --> 00:26:47.230
that I was destroying Alistair.
00:26:47.230 --> 00:26:49.774
- Oh, but it's also gay men,
00:26:49.774 --> 00:26:52.235
lesbian women, genuine bisexuals,
00:26:52.235 --> 00:26:54.195
not the faux bisexual I was.
00:26:55.030 --> 00:26:57.407
The transgender.
00:26:59.200 --> 00:27:03.121
The threat to heterosexuality
00:27:03.121 --> 00:27:07.167
is just still so fundamental.
00:27:08.501 --> 00:27:11.588
But everybody needs something
to hate, don't they?
00:27:11.588 --> 00:27:14.174
- This is where I'm feeling
myself getting very tense,
00:27:14.174 --> 00:27:16.384
because it is about hatred of change.
00:27:16.384 --> 00:27:19.262
It is about people holding
onto their privileges.
00:27:19.262 --> 00:27:21.014
I'm feeling very tense about it.
00:27:24.517 --> 00:27:28.688
"Mother Right" by Adrienne Rich, 1977,
00:27:31.232 --> 00:27:35.278
"Woman and child running in a field,
00:27:35.278 --> 00:27:38.239
a man planted on the horizon.
00:27:39.324 --> 00:27:42.160
Two hands, one long, slim,
00:27:42.160 --> 00:27:44.996
one small, starlike,
00:27:44.996 --> 00:27:47.916
clasped in the razor wind.
00:27:47.916 --> 00:27:51.169
Her hair, cut short for faster travel.
00:27:51.169 --> 00:27:54.547
The child's curls grazing his shoulders,
00:27:54.547 --> 00:27:58.927
and the hawk winged
cloud over their heads.
00:27:58.927 --> 00:28:03.223
The man is walking boundaries, measuring.
00:28:03.223 --> 00:28:05.976
He believes in what is his,
00:28:05.976 --> 00:28:07.060
the grass,
00:28:08.395 --> 00:28:10.563
the waters underneath,
00:28:10.563 --> 00:28:11.398
the air.
00:28:14.234 --> 00:28:19.155
The air through which child
and mother are running,
00:28:21.074 --> 00:28:23.076
the boy's singing,
00:28:23.076 --> 00:28:27.205
the woman, eyes sharpened in the light,
00:28:27.205 --> 00:28:31.126
heart thumping, making for the open."
00:28:33.753 --> 00:28:34.754
I read that a lot.
00:28:55.650 --> 00:28:57.610
- "I was so very glad to hear from you.
00:28:58.570 --> 00:29:03.033
I'm missing you very much
and it is grim and grinding.
00:29:04.075 --> 00:29:06.828
It is still raining, here in East Marion,
00:29:06.828 --> 00:29:10.623
and the roof is still
leaking over the bed.
00:29:10.623 --> 00:29:12.584
My ear aches.
00:29:12.584 --> 00:29:14.461
I want your body next to mine.
00:29:15.628 --> 00:29:18.590
Please finish up the nasty business
00:29:18.590 --> 00:29:21.217
and win the pretty prizes
00:29:21.217 --> 00:29:22.802
and come back where you belong.
00:29:23.762 --> 00:29:24.596
I love you.
00:29:25.430 --> 00:29:26.347
Your Kate."
00:29:30.852 --> 00:29:33.021
(laughing softly)
00:29:33.021 --> 00:29:37.192
Thursday, June 15, 10:00 AM
00:29:37.192 --> 00:29:39.861
"Hello, best beast.
00:29:39.861 --> 00:29:43.114
I'm sitting in a waiting
room at the family court.
00:29:43.114 --> 00:29:47.368
I'm in my court costume,
black skirt, stockings,
00:29:47.368 --> 00:29:49.329
red low-heeled shoes,
00:29:49.329 --> 00:29:54.125
smart knitted red-white camel
top over a black skivvy.
00:29:54.125 --> 00:29:58.963
Your/our ring, endless cigarettes."
00:30:00.215 --> 00:30:04.177
"Love, listen, the court
can decide against us,
00:30:05.386 --> 00:30:10.266
but it cannot destroy
you; the core of yourself.
00:30:11.351 --> 00:30:13.186
It cannot kill you.
00:30:14.479 --> 00:30:18.399
And darling, darling, when these horrible,
00:30:18.399 --> 00:30:20.443
distraught panics overwhelm you,
00:30:22.153 --> 00:30:24.280
remember that they will pass.
00:30:25.115 --> 00:30:28.451
Small duties, deep breaths
00:30:29.410 --> 00:30:31.746
and memories of your strengths."
00:30:34.040 --> 00:30:35.708
- [Judge] In the family court of Australia
00:30:35.708 --> 00:30:39.045
between Alistair Edward
Rose Wood, applicant,
00:30:39.045 --> 00:30:41.631
and Elizabeth Wood, respondent.
00:30:41.631 --> 00:30:42.674
- [Liz] What I then learned,
00:30:42.674 --> 00:30:44.551
because you'd then have
to give an affidavit,
00:30:44.551 --> 00:30:46.928
your lawyer gets that out of you.
00:30:46.928 --> 00:30:49.556
Alistair's lawyer was
doing the same with him.
00:30:49.556 --> 00:30:52.976
I learned that it was to
be a lesbian custody case,
00:30:52.976 --> 00:30:54.018
for a start.
00:30:54.018 --> 00:30:55.937
That I was an unfit mother.
00:30:55.937 --> 00:30:58.148
That was the term in those days.
00:30:58.148 --> 00:30:59.190
Why was I unfit?
00:30:59.190 --> 00:31:00.859
Because I was a lesbian
00:31:00.859 --> 00:31:03.403
and because I had formed a relationship
00:31:03.403 --> 00:31:07.157
with the so-called Professor
Stimpson in New York.
00:31:07.991 --> 00:31:09.826
So it was clear it was going to be
00:31:09.826 --> 00:31:11.911
a custody case of an unfit mother
00:31:11.911 --> 00:31:14.455
who wanted to go to New York,
00:31:14.455 --> 00:31:16.082
because she had a lover there.
00:31:16.082 --> 00:31:19.127
- The stupidest thing I could have done
00:31:20.587 --> 00:31:23.381
would be no matter how
nicely dressed I was,
00:31:23.381 --> 00:31:26.050
no matter how good my manners were,
00:31:26.050 --> 00:31:28.344
the so-called Professor Stimpson
00:31:28.344 --> 00:31:30.555
to show up in court and sit there going,
00:31:30.555 --> 00:31:32.307
Muah! Good luck, honey!
00:31:32.307 --> 00:31:34.267
- No, I had to be,
00:31:35.310 --> 00:31:37.687
I had to be as invisible as possible.
00:31:37.687 --> 00:31:38.605
- The lawyer said,
00:31:39.606 --> 00:31:43.610
if the judge and the
other lawyers in the room
00:31:43.610 --> 00:31:45.445
see the two of you together,
00:31:45.445 --> 00:31:48.364
they will then see you as a lesbian
00:31:49.532 --> 00:31:51.242
and you are in court as a mother.
00:31:52.285 --> 00:31:54.037
And the first time I went into court,
00:31:54.037 --> 00:31:55.330
it became very clear
00:31:55.330 --> 00:31:59.125
that he was going to ask
for complete custody.
00:31:59.125 --> 00:32:00.376
- [Lawyer] Several years ago,
00:32:00.376 --> 00:32:02.670
she ceased to sleep in
the same room with you?
00:32:03.546 --> 00:32:04.589
- [Alastair] Yes.
00:32:04.589 --> 00:32:05.798
- [Lawyer] And told, by your wife,
00:32:05.798 --> 00:32:08.176
that the marriage was over?
00:32:08.176 --> 00:32:10.595
- [Alastair] Yes, that the
marriage was absolutely all over
00:32:10.595 --> 00:32:12.847
and she had decided she was a lesbian
00:32:12.847 --> 00:32:15.433
and had been for some time, really.
00:32:15.433 --> 00:32:18.853
- "I sometimes feel I'm
supporting everyone;
00:32:18.853 --> 00:32:22.482
as if they all thought I
didn't need support myself.
00:32:22.482 --> 00:32:25.193
What a crazy situation it is.
00:32:25.193 --> 00:32:29.364
No matter which way up or
down you turn it, I'm a loser.
00:32:29.364 --> 00:32:31.324
Either I abandoned my kids,
00:32:31.324 --> 00:32:34.244
or I've ripped the poor
father's life in twain.
00:32:35.078 --> 00:32:38.248
If I show any pain, I'm incompetent.
00:32:38.248 --> 00:32:40.959
If I'm strong, I'm a bitch."
00:32:42.043 --> 00:32:46.673
- "You're under the
pressures of war, real war.
00:32:46.673 --> 00:32:48.800
and you're responding magnificently.
00:32:49.717 --> 00:32:51.844
Ali is mean, isn't he?
00:32:53.137 --> 00:32:55.974
But you know who the enemy is
00:32:56.975 --> 00:32:59.560
and you need not struggle
00:32:59.560 --> 00:33:02.689
under the burden of guilt."
00:33:02.689 --> 00:33:04.274
- What was it that Alastair wanted?
00:33:04.274 --> 00:33:05.191
Because it seemed to me,
00:33:05.191 --> 00:33:06.859
it wasn't anything to do with
00:33:06.859 --> 00:33:09.320
the welfare of the children.
00:33:09.320 --> 00:33:12.907
I had to understand that we were property.
00:33:12.907 --> 00:33:14.200
The children were property.
00:33:14.200 --> 00:33:16.244
This was about the possessiveness
00:33:16.244 --> 00:33:17.829
of the patriarchal family,
00:33:17.829 --> 00:33:19.580
who owns what?
00:33:20.623 --> 00:33:22.625
- "I have just talked to Adrienne Rich.
00:33:23.668 --> 00:33:26.713
I called her yesterday to check in,
00:33:27.630 --> 00:33:28.840
in need of her wisdom.
00:33:30.300 --> 00:33:32.260
I told her the story.
00:33:32.260 --> 00:33:35.471
She sends you courage and strength.
00:33:35.471 --> 00:33:39.017
Men will, when pressed in any way,
00:33:39.976 --> 00:33:42.103
never be reasonable.
00:33:43.855 --> 00:33:46.858
Ali will be as bad as he possibly can be."
00:33:47.859 --> 00:33:50.320
- [Lawyer] Have you mentioned
the word "lesbianism"
00:33:50.320 --> 00:33:51.863
to your daughters?
00:33:51.863 --> 00:33:53.031
- [Liz] Yes.
00:33:53.031 --> 00:33:54.782
- [Lawyer] How have you explained it?
00:33:54.782 --> 00:33:56.659
- [Liz] I don't remember the exact terms
00:33:56.659 --> 00:33:58.244
in which I discussed it.
00:33:58.244 --> 00:33:59.829
When I discuss things with the children,
00:33:59.829 --> 00:34:01.497
it's usually in terms of their age
00:34:01.497 --> 00:34:03.458
and their ability to understand.
00:34:03.458 --> 00:34:04.292
- [Lawyer] I would take it
00:34:04.292 --> 00:34:05.376
that you would not like your daughters
00:34:05.376 --> 00:34:08.296
to become lesbians, would you?
00:34:08.296 --> 00:34:09.756
- [Liz] I think the lasting attachment
00:34:09.756 --> 00:34:12.258
and the long-term
relationship matters more
00:34:12.258 --> 00:34:14.761
than the aspects of what people do in bed.
00:34:15.636 --> 00:34:17.638
That's when I found out about
00:34:17.638 --> 00:34:19.724
who would appear in court.
00:34:19.724 --> 00:34:23.895
And we'd already planned who we needed
00:34:23.895 --> 00:34:25.563
and who had offered to.
00:34:25.563 --> 00:34:27.732
And the first person to offer,
00:34:27.732 --> 00:34:29.776
was the headmistress of the school
00:34:29.776 --> 00:34:31.778
where the three girls went.
00:34:31.778 --> 00:34:33.529
- [Lawyer] I call Mrs. Berman,
00:34:33.529 --> 00:34:36.199
headmistress of the wilderness school.
00:34:36.199 --> 00:34:38.618
- She called me into her office formally,
00:34:38.618 --> 00:34:42.455
and she said, please tell
me, what is a lesbian?
00:34:42.455 --> 00:34:45.708
Greta, her hands were clutching
00:34:45.708 --> 00:34:47.627
the edge of her desk, white.
00:34:48.544 --> 00:34:51.923
And so I told her what I was,
00:34:51.923 --> 00:34:53.383
and we talked about the children.
00:34:53.383 --> 00:34:56.219
And she just, she let go.
00:34:56.219 --> 00:34:57.178
And that was when I knew,
00:34:57.178 --> 00:34:58.805
she would probably be there
00:34:58.805 --> 00:35:00.181
to support me in some way,
00:35:00.181 --> 00:35:01.474
but I didn't know how.
00:35:01.474 --> 00:35:03.309
And I never forget her courage,
00:35:03.309 --> 00:35:05.853
because she was literally shaking,
00:35:05.853 --> 00:35:08.272
falling apart with fear.
00:35:08.272 --> 00:35:09.690
- [Lawyer] Have you, in the time
00:35:09.690 --> 00:35:12.068
their father was solely responsible,
00:35:12.068 --> 00:35:15.822
noticed anything in
respect to the children?
00:35:15.822 --> 00:35:17.532
- [Headmistress] Last year in particular,
00:35:17.532 --> 00:35:19.534
when they were looked
after by their father,
00:35:19.534 --> 00:35:22.662
they were often looking unkept.
00:35:22.662 --> 00:35:25.623
The hair wasn't properly looked after.
00:35:25.623 --> 00:35:27.834
They were very tired and very drawn,
00:35:27.834 --> 00:35:29.836
as though they didn't get enough sleep.
00:35:29.836 --> 00:35:32.255
They often would be
without their school books
00:35:32.255 --> 00:35:33.381
or their music books,
00:35:33.381 --> 00:35:34.507
or their sports gear.
00:35:36.092 --> 00:35:37.885
- "My hunch about the outcome,
00:35:38.761 --> 00:35:40.680
I think I could lose.
00:35:40.680 --> 00:35:44.517
But that if I did, I would
be ultimately winning.
00:35:44.517 --> 00:35:48.938
My other hunch being, that
I would try again next year,
00:35:48.938 --> 00:35:52.817
next year and the next and the next,
00:35:52.817 --> 00:35:53.860
that I wouldn't give up
00:35:53.860 --> 00:35:58.030
what I feel is my natural,
as well as earned, rights.
00:35:58.030 --> 00:36:00.491
And all the time Ali will know,
00:36:00.491 --> 00:36:02.034
and be made to know,
00:36:02.034 --> 00:36:04.454
that I can never be kept away from my kids
00:36:04.454 --> 00:36:06.372
if they and I wish to be together."
00:36:07.665 --> 00:36:09.167
- [Kate On Tape] Just remember darling,
00:36:09.167 --> 00:36:10.877
no matter what has happened,
00:36:10.877 --> 00:36:13.171
we are together and we will fight.
00:36:14.464 --> 00:36:16.883
We will do the best we can.
00:36:16.883 --> 00:36:19.802
We'll let the children be
hurt as little as possible.
00:36:21.304 --> 00:36:25.558
We will not succumb to
this fucking patriarchy.
00:36:25.558 --> 00:36:28.686
We will not give them any more power.
00:36:29.520 --> 00:36:31.647
I love you and I wait for you.
00:36:31.647 --> 00:36:33.232
Goodnight darling."
00:36:35.651 --> 00:36:37.069
- When I got the phone call
00:36:39.155 --> 00:36:41.282
that Liz had been appointed joint custody
00:36:41.282 --> 00:36:43.951
and the family was coming,
00:36:43.951 --> 00:36:45.995
everyone was astonished.
00:36:45.995 --> 00:36:48.456
- "So we've done it, darling.
00:36:48.456 --> 00:36:50.708
We've really done it.
00:36:50.708 --> 00:36:54.086
That bobby-caped woman
you met on the Bowery
00:36:54.086 --> 00:36:55.755
is truly free now,
00:36:55.755 --> 00:36:59.759
and you were absolutely right
in your first instincts.
00:36:59.759 --> 00:37:01.761
And you can absolutely stay
00:37:01.761 --> 00:37:04.096
right there in love with her,
00:37:04.096 --> 00:37:04.931
thank you."
00:37:08.392 --> 00:37:13.356
♪ Who can turn the world
on with her smile ♪
00:37:13.564 --> 00:37:16.025
♪ Who can make a nothing day ♪
00:37:16.025 --> 00:37:18.277
♪ Suddenly make it all seem worth while ♪
00:37:18.277 --> 00:37:21.155
♪ Well it's you girl
and you should know it ♪
00:37:21.155 --> 00:37:23.032
♪ With each glance and
every little movement ♪
00:37:23.032 --> 00:37:25.284
- We were in Washington DC,
00:37:25.284 --> 00:37:28.996
and the three grandchildren
were in the backseat.
00:37:28.996 --> 00:37:31.749
And one says, rather mischievously,
00:37:33.584 --> 00:37:35.336
"Are you two married?"
00:37:37.046 --> 00:37:37.964
And the other says,
00:37:37.964 --> 00:37:40.508
with total contempt for her ignorance,
00:37:41.425 --> 00:37:43.803
"No, they're lifelong partners."
00:37:45.054 --> 00:37:48.266
And at which point, Liz's son,
00:37:48.266 --> 00:37:51.602
now my stepson, whom I just adore,
00:37:51.602 --> 00:37:53.020
- Our son.
00:37:53.020 --> 00:37:56.983
- Said, and why not, you two?
00:37:58.359 --> 00:37:59.193
And
00:38:00.778 --> 00:38:03.030
it was, yes!
00:38:03.030 --> 00:38:03.990
♪ I don't know what it is ♪
00:38:03.990 --> 00:38:06.409
♪ That makes me love you so ♪
00:38:06.409 --> 00:38:09.954
♪ I only know I never wanna let you go ♪
00:38:09.954 --> 00:38:11.664
♪ Cause you started something, ♪
00:38:11.664 --> 00:38:13.624
♪ Oh can't you see ♪
00:38:13.624 --> 00:38:14.834
♪ That ever since we met ♪
00:38:14.834 --> 00:38:17.128
♪ You had a hold on me ♪
00:38:17.128 --> 00:38:20.715
♪ It happens to be true, ♪
00:38:20.715 --> 00:38:25.720
♪ I only wanna be with you ♪
00:38:30.308 --> 00:38:33.561
(gentle country music)
00:38:41.319 --> 00:38:43.863
♪ I am woman hear me roar ♪
00:38:43.863 --> 00:38:46.782
♪ In numbers too big to ignore. ♪
00:38:46.782 --> 00:38:51.787
♪ And I know too much
to go back and pretend ♪
00:38:52.496 --> 00:38:55.124
♪ Because I've heard it all before ♪
00:38:55.124 --> 00:38:58.002
♪ And I've been down there on the floor. ♪
00:38:58.002 --> 00:39:03.007
♪ No one's ever going
to keep me down again. ♪
00:39:04.717 --> 00:39:06.552
♪ Yes, I am wise ♪
00:39:06.552 --> 00:39:10.056
♪ But it's wisdom born of pain ♪
00:39:10.056 --> 00:39:12.600
♪ Yes, I paid the price ♪
00:39:12.600 --> 00:39:15.186
♪ But look how much I gained ♪
00:39:15.186 --> 00:39:20.191
♪ If I have to, I can do anything. ♪
00:39:20.775 --> 00:39:23.235
♪ I'm strong, strong ♪
00:39:23.235 --> 00:39:26.405
♪ I am invincible, invincible ♪
00:39:26.405 --> 00:39:30.368
♪ I am woman ♪
Distributor: GOOD DOCS
Length: 39 minutes
Date: 2024
Genre: Expository
Language: English
Grade: 10-12, College, Adults
Color/BW:
Closed Captioning: Available
Please log in to your public library's site to view this film.